No. 01
Italian Ice
Bright, sharp, and made next door at our sister shop.
Old-fashioned ice cream parlor
Ottaway’s
Parkside Ice Cream Parlor
Authentic Amish ice cream made by Yoder’s Creamery — over forty hand-dipped flavors, an attached candy shop, and pressed Cubans, served from a corner spot in downtown New Port Richey since 2015.
5641 Main StNew Port Richey, FL
· Across from Sims Park
4.6· 706 Google reviews
Over 40 Hand-Dipped Flavors
Today on the Board
The Flavors
Made by Yoder’s Creamery, in the Amish tradition. Hand-dipped one scoop at a time.
~ Scoops & Signatures ~
- 01
Triple Peanut Butter Shake
the house favorite — peanut butter three ways
- 02
Espresso Shake
real espresso, slow-pulled, hand-spun
- 03
Cookie Butter
speculoos crumb folded through sweet cream
- 04
Kahlua Krunch
coffee liqueur, chocolate-covered crunch
- 05
Trashcan
everything but the kitchen sink — and proud of it
- 06
Banana Pudding
wafers, ripe banana, vanilla bean
- 07
Coffeehouse Crunch
dark roast with toffee bits
- 08
Cherry Cardinal
tart cherries swirled in vanilla
- 09
Pumpkin Cheesecake
fall in a scoop, every season
…and 30+ more, hand-dipped daily
“More flavors of hand-dipped ice cream than Baskin Robbins.” — Google review, 2024
Triple Peanut ButterEspresso ShakeCookie ButterKahlua KrunchTrashcanBanana PuddingCoffeehouse CrunchCherry CardinalPumpkin CheesecakeMaple WalnutBlack RaspberrySalted CaramelButter PecanMint Chocolate ChipStrawberry CheesecakeOld-Fashioned VanillaTriple Peanut ButterEspresso ShakeCookie ButterKahlua KrunchTrashcanBanana PuddingCoffeehouse CrunchCherry CardinalPumpkin CheesecakeMaple WalnutBlack RaspberrySalted CaramelButter PecanMint Chocolate ChipStrawberry CheesecakeOld-Fashioned Vanilla
also at the shop
More Than Ice Cream
No. 02
Hand-Made Shakes
Spun the old way. Triple peanut butter is the one to beat.
No. 03
Old-Fashioned Floats
Root beer, orange cream, black cow — a tall glass and a long straw.
No. 04
Sandwiches & Cubans
Pressed Cubans, hot dogs, and a short menu done right.
No. 05
The Candy Shop
Wooden drawers of penny-style candy, just like the corner store.
No. 06
Pup Cups for Dogs
A little something for the four-legged regulars.
The Corner of Main & Sims
family-owned since 2015
Kim & Mike Ottaway
Kim and Mike opened the parlor in 2015 with a simple idea: bring real, hand-dipped ice cream — the kind they remembered as kids — to the corner of Main Street, right across from Sims Park. They source every flavor from Yoder’s Creamery, an Amish dairy that still makes ice cream the slow way.
Ten years on, the same family runs the shop, the candy drawers, the Italian-ice window next door, and the kitchen that turns out the Cubans regulars come back for. Nothing about it is corporate. That’s the point.
“Family owned and it shows.”
Come on By
The Spot
Make a day of it — we’re open late on weekends.
Illustration
5641 Main St
find us
5641 Main Street
New Port Richey, FL 34652
hours
| Mon–Thu | 11am – 10pm |
| Fri & Sat | 11am – 11pm |
| Sunday | 11am – 10pm |
“Worth the diversion off US-19.”
— Google review, 2024
Say Hello